This is incredibly difficult. I’m a big fan of both of these sculpts. I heaped praise on both
#219 and
#177.
#177 doesn’t have a glaring weakness. It has a great look, great sculpt, playable pose, and scores near the top of every category. If there is one weakness it is the reptilian nature of the figure. But it’s a minor flaw. This figure really seems like a dragon in armor, so while it’s similar it’s different enough.
#219 weakness is that it is another Muscleman figure, but it’s seemingly the only action orientated figure (#208 is the only other one that remotely fits the bill, off the top of my head). If there were lots of figures with action poses, then it would lose some of that special-ness.
But this isn’t about the entire line. It’s about two figures. And for me, #177 is the stronger figure on his own – although he gets the win by a few percentage points. #219 could have gone further with a different draw.
My vote is for #177.